2018
ACHA W2: University of Delaware, Liberty University, University at Buffalo
2017
ACHA W2: University at Buffalo, University of Delaware, United States Naval Academy
NCHA: Penn State Altoona (2nd)
2016
ACHA W2: University at Buffalo, California University of PA, University of Delaware, West Chester University
ACHA M3: California University of PA
NCHA: Penn State Altoona (2nd), Saint Vincent College (4th)
2015
ACHA W2: California University of PA, West Chester University (2nd)
ACHA M3: California University of PA, University of Pittsburgh at Johnstown
NCHA: University of Pittsburgh at Greensburg (2nd)
2014
ACHA W2: Penn State University (2nd), California University of PA (4th), West Chester University, University of Delaware
ACHA M3: California University of PA, University of Pittsburgh at Johnstown
CIHA: University of Pittsburgh at Greensburg (1st)
2013
ACHA M3: California University of PA
2012
ACHA M3: California University of PA
2011
ACHA M3: California University of PA
2010
ACHA M3: California University of PA, Fredonia State University
2009
ACHA M3: Fredonia State University
2008
ACHA M3: California University of PA (1st)
2007
ACHA M3: California University of PA
2006
ACHA M3: University of Pittsburgh at Johnstown
2005
ACHA M3: California University of PA, University of Pittsburgh at Johnstown
OTHER
Robert Morris: 2002 ACHA M3 (1st)
Indiana U of PA: 1999 ACHA M2
Penn State - M2: 1997 ACHA M2 (2nd)
Note: appearances are listed only for years in which team was a CHE/WPCHA member